Taking a long-term perspective when measuring superannuation returns ignores risk and fails to take into account the behaviour of members, according to actuarial services provider Milliman.
Milliman practice leader Wade Matterson said in a blog that, while measuring returns for investors is relatively simple, measuring risk is where the challenge lies.
He said investor behaviour is “often driven by emotion-charged cognitive failures”.
Mr Matterson said the Productivity Commission’s draft report, How to assess the superannuation system’s performance, suggests that system-wide average net returns reflect the impact of diversification and market volatility and “is in line with the industry’s view that a long-term measure of 20 years effectively captures risk-adjusted returns”.
However, he noted this projection unfortunately “doesn’t reflect the reality of investors”.
“A 20-year long-term perspective may effectively capture risk-adjusted returns but it doesn’t reflect the damaging risk of investor behaviour, which all too often destroys real returns,” Mr Matterson said.
“Ultimately, risk must be linked to a member’s goals.”
Mr Matterson said that linking risk to member goals requires funds to use greater actuarial and technical firepower to analyse the disparate needs of their members, and to make far fewer assumptions about what their members require.
He said, for example, that the super industry regularly relies on ‘comfortable retirement’ measures even though those measures often neglect money and assets outside of super.
“The only way to find out this information is to forge a far closer relationship with members,” Mr Matterson said.
“This will, in turn, underpin more tailored communications, investment strategies and product solutions.
“This is a harder path for funds but one that will differentiate them from other funds and create closer ties with members.”
Read more:
Banks falling short on consumer initiatives
Property investors could force RBA's hand
Australian bank oligopoly ‘alive and well’
Regular managed accounts ‘census’ announced
Supervised Investments names new CEO
Adrian Flores is a features editor at Momentum Media, focusing mainly on banking, wealth management and financial services. He has also written for Public Accountant, Accountants Daily and The CEO Magazine.
You can contact him on [email protected]
Natixis Investment Management firm Flexstone Partners has secured a US$100 million ($138.5 million) private equity mandate from Hostplus. ...
Superannuation fund members are spending almost $35 billion on fees every year according to a new report, which has also named AMP, OnePath ...
Almost $600 million will be returned to the superannuation accounts of 400,000 Australians due to the one-off superannuation amnesty. ...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Copyright © 2020 Investor Daily
Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.
Read More