Review minimum withdrawal rates: Morningstar

Tim Stewart
— 1 minute read

Australian retirees are likely to exhaust their superannuation before they die at the current minimum withdrawal rates, warns investment research house Morningstar.

New research by Morningstar suggests Australian retirees can only afford to withdraw 2.5 per cent of their allocated pension each year if they want to be certain it will last for 30 years.

A new Morningstar paper titled Safe Withdrawal Rates for Australian Retirees casts doubt on the '4 per cent rule' for pension withdrawals, popularised by US financial planner William Bengen in 1994.


The Morningstar paper concludes that financial advisers and retirees should use "lower initial safe withdrawal rates than noted in prior research".

"The lower end of the range now starts towards 2.5 per cent and not the previous 4.0 per cent," it said.

The findings have ramifications for the minimum annual payment that account-based pensions are required to make to beneficiaries.

Currently, account-based pensions must pay 4 per cent per year to beneficiaries aged under 65; 5 per cent a year to beneficiaries aged between 65 and 74; and 6 per cent to beneficiaries aged between 75 and 79.

Presenting the paper in Sydney, Morningstar managing director for research strategy in Asia Pacific, Anthony Serhan, said the Turnbull government should review minimum withdrawal rates.

Any review of the rules should take into account the fact that equity return expectations have been "reset" in recent years, Mr Serhan said, as well as the fact that life expectancy is steadily increasing.

"Under current law, account-based pensions aren’t an estate planning tool. They’re meant to pay you a pension which you either spend, or you can reinvest in a normal environment," Mr Serhan said.

It is also perfectly reasonable for the government to want to limit the amount of money that remains in the tax-incentivised environment of superannuation, he said.

"[But] there is a trade off. You can force people to take out a higher minimum level, but the trade-off there is you’re also increasing the probability that they are going to need the age pension sooner at some point," Mr Serhan said.

"And based on our analysis and our projections moving forward, these rates are going to diminish capital more quickly than what we would say is the safe withdrawal rate."

More to come:

Conditions ripe for corporate takeovers

Responsible investment a ‘must have’ capability

ISA rejects disclosure carve-out for retail funds

Hedge funds outperform equities in 2015: AIMA

Kardinia Capital hires senior analyst


Review minimum withdrawal rates: Morningstar
investordaily image
ID logo


related articles

promoted stories

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.