Is talk of a new Great Depression overblown?

By Lachlan Maddock
 — 1 minute read

An extraordinary government response means that the world is unlikely to see a repeat of the Great Depression.

While millions are now unemployed and the world’s largest financial institutions are grappling with forecasts of a prolonged and devastating recession, we aren’t where we were after the Great Crash of 1929. 

“I do not agree with comparisons to the Great Depression given the stark difference in the fiscal and monetary policy responses,” said Franklin Templeton head of equities Stephen Dover. “During the Great Depression, policymakers tightened monetary policy, misdirected fiscal aid, raised trade barriers and increased the regulatory burden on banks and industry. Policymakers have learned from that mistake; the current global response has been the opposite.”


The Great Depression in Australia saw both the state and federal governments adopt deflationary policies, moving to balance their budgets as incomes fell and unemployment rose. While that move was welcomed at the time, it was later viewed to have aggravated the crisis and led to a more protracted period of unemployment. The coronavirus crisis has seen the government move to support employment and maintain consumer spending through a series of surplus packages. 

The outlook for equities is also more favourable, with a strong government response and the fact that the crisis is health driven putting a floor beneath falling prices. 

“As we are better able to access the length, health consequences and costs of the virus, the volatility in the markets is likely to abate,” Mr Dover said. “Companies are strengthening their balance sheets: the results may be that companies will need to have stronger balance sheets going forward and investors, especially individuals, will need to have larger ‘rainy day accounts.’”

“In a world where central banks lower government bond yields to at or, in some cases, below zero, and governments are adding massive fiscal spending, equities should outperform dramatically in relative terms… I also expect some support to equities as institutions and retail investors, especially in balanced funds, rebalance their portfolios.”


Is talk of a new Great Depression overblown?
investordaily image
ID logo


related articles

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.