Passive ‘falls over’ in emerging markets

Passive ‘falls over’ in emerging markets

— 1 minute read

Passive investment strategies perform well in developed markets like Australia, but investors should be wary of using them in inefficient emerging markets, says India Avenue Investment Management.

Investors should adopt a horses for courses approach when it comes to investing overseas, says India Avenue Investment Management managing director Mugunthan Siva. 

What works in a developed, more efficient market such as Australia may not work abroad. Convenience and cheapness do not necessarily equate to a better proposition for clients, Mr Siva said.


Passive products such as ETFs work well in efficient markets like the US and Australia, but they fall over when they are used in inefficient emerging markets such as China and India.

Research shows that ETFs have dramatically underperformed active managers in these markets. Accessing these markets via ETF means you are leaving returns on the table, Mr Siva said.

India has more than 6,000 companies listed on its two main exchanges, but institutional brokers only research the top 100 to 150 stocks in detail.

If you buy an index strategy for India, you will be holding the good and the bad, including companies which may have corporate governance issues, Mr Siva said.

There is a gulf in valuations and performance between companies with strong and not-so-strong corporate governance in India. Only active management can target these well-run companies.

Read more:

CBA defends CommInsure review

NAB boss questioned about breach reporting

Market reaction to Trump's speech overblown

Interim Praemium CEO named

VanEck grows investment team


Passive ‘falls over’ in emerging markets
India Avenue Investment Management, India, Australia, ETF, passive, active, Mugunthan Siva
ID logo

related articles

  • Major banks update home lending policy

    Two of the big four banks have updated their home loan serviceability assessment policy in response to APRA’s regulatory amendments. ...

  • Aus ETFs surpass $50bn

    The Australian exchange-traded fund industry has overtaken the $50-billion milestone, according to the newly published report by BetaShares....

  • Banking reputation at rock bottom

    One chief executive has said that the reputation of bankers was at rock bottom and hoped that it would not get any worse. ...

promoted stories

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.