X
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Events
Subscribe to our Newsletter
  • News
    • Markets
    • Regulation
    • Super
    • M&A
    • Tech
    • Appointments
  • Podcast
  • Webcasts
  • Video
  • Analysis
  • Promoted Content
No Results
View All Results
  • News
    • Markets
    • Regulation
    • Super
    • M&A
    • Tech
    • Appointments
  • Podcast
  • Webcasts
  • Video
  • Analysis
  • Promoted Content
No Results
View All Results
No Results
View All Results
Home Analysis

Active v passive debate: Ignore ‘either-or’ and choose ‘both’

The active versus passive debate is a perennial but misplaced one. Striking the ideal balance between the two distinct investments can greatly influence the overall success and resilience of an investment portfolio in the long run.

by Emanuel Datt
November 30, 2021
in Analysis
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Active investing within the fund management space seeks to utilise a hands-on approach to capital accumulation and preservation, benefiting from extensive research functions within investment teams that work in pursuit of discovering attractive investments within the marketplace.

The main benefit from passive investing is within the low maintenance nature of allocating capital into particular investment classes or indices without the need of undertaking extensive analytical market research. Investors should be mindful that low-cost passive market exposure may come at higher potential downside risk.

X

Risk reward

Risk management plays a pivotal role in both investment styles.

In particular, active investing facilitates fund managers to deploy highly involved strategies that are designed to generate returns regardless of the underlying economic environment. Such tactics may include capturing short-term opportunities, downside protection and appropriate sector allocation. Active fund managers are therefore better equipped to dynamically respond to such circumstances and may benefit those investors who are willing to broaden their risk tolerance to capture returns throughout the economic cycle.

Portfolio diversification 

For experienced investors looking to diversify their portfolios, the added versatility of active investment may be a crucial element in ensuring that the level of risk vs reward is appropriately sustained. In essence, the difference between an experienced investor (such as a retiree) looking to generate returns, and an inexperienced younger investor simply investing in passive investments in the long-term is fundamentally differentiated from the impacts of time, willingness to take risk and their understanding of emerging and evolving new markets.

Younger investors may sway towards passive style investments, as the quality of the investment class over the long run may better suit their financial needs.

On the other hand, experienced investors may be seeking to preserve capital and benefit from returns that may be generated without the underlying influence of time, in which case, active investment may be more suitable. While younger investors may be more willing to allocate 100 per cent of their portfolio to passive investments such as ETFs, experienced investors may consider assigning a 40:60 ratio of active to passive investment. This ratio can be tailored to the individuals’ financial needs and circumstances. 

Performance

Equity investments over the past three years have generated substantial returns to managed funds, such as Datt Capital’s Absolute Return Fund, which achieved 17.27 per cent per annum after fees (as at September 2021) within that time. Comparatively, the ASX 200 index achieved 11.92 per cent p.a, exemplifying the consistent yet lower return nature of some conservative indices. 

Striking the balance between active equity investment funds and other passive investments such as ETFs and the like can essentially provide investors with the best of both worlds, with the associated risk and return to be proportionally embedded within a particular portfolio. Experienced investors, therefore, may consider allocating a portion of their portfolio to both.

Emanuel Datt is the founder and CIO of Datt Capital.

Related Posts

The Role Reversal: Emerging Risks in the World’s Mature Economies

by Stefan Magnusson, Emerging Markets Portfolio Manager, Orbis
November 17, 2025

Stefan Magnusson discusses why investors – especially in Australia – may wish to rethink emerging market risk and seize overlooked...

Shifting Australian equity market leadership presents opportunities

by Cameron Gleeson, Betashares Senior Investment Strategist
November 14, 2025

After years of large caps driving the domestic sharemarket, leadership is shifting to the mid and small cap segment.

How does free float impact stock returns?

by Abhishek Gupta
November 11, 2025

Free float — the number of company shares outstanding — is a quiet but powerful lever in equity markets. The...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

VIEW ALL
Promoted Content

Global dividends hit a Q3 record, led by financials.

Global dividends surged to a record US$518.7 billion in Q3 2025, up 6.2% year-on-year, with financials leading the way. The...

by Capital Group
November 18, 2025
Promoted Content

Why smaller can be smarter in private credit

Over the past 15 years, middle market direct lending has grown into one of the most dynamic areas of alternative...

by Tim Warrick, Managing Director of Principal Alternative Credit, Principal Asset Management
November 14, 2025
Promoted Content

Members Want Super Funds to Step Up Security

For most Australians, superannuation is their largest financial asset outside the family home. So, when it comes to digital security,...

by MUFG Pension & Market Services
October 3, 2025
Promoted Content

Boring Can Be Brilliant: Why Steady Investing Builds Lasting Wealth

In financial markets, drama makes headlines. Share prices surge, tumble, and rebound — creating the stories that capture attention. But...

by Zagga
October 2, 2025

Join our newsletter

View our privacy policy, collection notice and terms and conditions to understand how we use your personal information.

Latest Podcast

Podcast

Relative Return Insider: Economic shifts, political crossroads, and the digital future

by InvestorDaily team
November 13, 2025
After more than two decades, InvestorDaily continues to be an institution that connects and influences Australia’s financial services sector. This influential and integrated media brand connects with leading financial services professionals within superannuation, funds management, financial planning and intermediary distribution through a range of channels, including digital, social, research, broadcast, webcast and events.

Subscribe to our newsletter

View our privacy policy, collection notice and terms and conditions to understand how we use your personal information.

About Us

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Collection Notice
  • Privacy Policy

Popular Topics

  • Markets
  • Appointments
  • Regulation
  • Super
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Tech
  • Promoted Content
  • Analysis

© 2025 All Rights Reserved. All content published on this site is the property of Prime Creative Media. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited

No Results
View All Results
NEWSLETTER
  • News
  • Markets
  • Regulation
  • Super
  • M&A
  • Tech
  • Appointments
  • Podcast
  • Webcasts
  • Promoted Content
  • Events
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us

© 2025 All Rights Reserved. All content published on this site is the property of Prime Creative Media. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited