Top planners say the Government is stuck for solutions amid the mortgage fund redemption surge debacle.
Top financial advisers say the Federal Government is struggling to find solutions to the mortgage fund redemption issue, and risks more unintended consequences if it moves to guarantee the products.
Asset managers including Perpetual, Axa, Challenger and Australian Unity and smaller managers have frozen over $20 billion worth of property, mortgage and income funds since last week.
Invamore Financial director Paul Daily, and HPH Solutions partner Adam Smith, both winners of the recent AFA Adviser of the Year award, said little could be done now.
"The surge of redemptions in mortgage funds is tied to what is happening generally in markets at present," Daily said, referring to investor confidence.
"But if the Government moves to guarantee them, people will be moving out of fixed-interest and bond funds. The Government may also be pressured to then guarantee these investments. I am not sure what the answer is."
It is not the Government's role to guarantee investors' funds or deposits, he said. "If you are an investor and you want a government guarantee, the traditional security has been a 10-Year Treasury Bond - it delivers returns albeit at a much lower rate," Daily said.
"Now the Government has made deposits like a Treasury Bond, so why would you want to be a bond holder? What is going to happen to the bond market?"
Made impulsively during a crisis meeting on October 11 and 12, the Government's banking guarantee was understandable, however, there needed to be more thorough discussions on its consequences, Smith said.
"This is the issue the Government has created now. It is obvious that a lot of people want to extract their funds and put [their money] into more secure areas," he said.
The Government could extend its bank to mortgage funds, but risks investors demanding the same protection for mutual funds, he said.
In Part 2 of our exclusive series, we ask leading names to nominate their best investments, the most effective industry group and the importance of platforms.
British Prime Minister Gordon Brown last month uttered the 'R' word. Brown told parliament Britain will "most likely" head towards a recession. A view also shared by the country's central bank chief. ... read more »
Home delivered!
Daily news, weekday mornings
Get the day's news delivered direct to your inbox. Register here (it's free!) and choose 'yes' to receive the InvestorDaily newsletter.
Catholics revamp fixed interest »
Industry superannuation fund the Catholic Superannuation and Retirement Fund (CSRF) has revamped its fixed income portfolio.
Mercer backs alternatives »
Mercer has awarded $34.15 million in mandates to Tactical Global Management (TGM) and Lazard Asset Management to invest in alternative assets.
Some companies are forecasting their second-half results will be better than their first half, but this is nonsense. According to equities analysts, it's going to be a very ugly period.... read more »
