APRA has released new research comparing the costs of industry superannuation funds with retail funds.
Australia's industry superannuation market has overshadowed its retail fund rivals in a comparative test of fees, asset allocation and investment expenses, according to new data from The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA).
APRA released the research results late yesterday, on the performance of large APRA-regulated superannuation funds from July 1, 2001 to 30 June 30, 2006.
The research found there are few statistically significant differences in returns between corporate, public sector and industry funds (not-for-profit funds). However, the study found that the main difference in net returns between fund types is due to expenses.
Retail fund expenses, explicit and embedded, lowered the net earnings of the retail sector, relative to the not-for-profit sector.
"I think what needs to be said about the outcomes is these are averages... consumers and advisers need to look at individual performance... in order to make valid conclusions," Investment and Financial Services Association (IFSA) chief executive Richard Gilbert said..
In relation to investment management performance, while there is market similarity, retail funds have, on average, come out more expensive overall because of advice, he said.
"Consumers need to be on the ball to get this advice and that is critical. I am sure that consumers who have had advice about moving their assets in the last six months... will be very happy to pay for it," Gilbert said.
The study examined a representative sample of 90 corporate, industry, public sector and retail superannuation funds, each with more than $200 million in assets as at June 30, 2005.
The research was commissioned by the Council of Financial Regulators and is published on the APRA website.
In Part 2 of our exclusive series, we ask leading names to nominate their best investments, the most effective industry group and the importance of platforms.
A former colleague of mine once offered the opinion that industry superannuation funds are reconstructed socialists - despite their union influence, these funds have grown and benefited from a global capitalist world.... read more »
Home delivered!
Daily news, weekday mornings
Get the day's news delivered direct to your inbox. Register here (it's free!) and choose 'yes' to receive the InvestorDaily newsletter.
Catholics revamp fixed interest »
Industry superannuation fund the Catholic Superannuation and Retirement Fund (CSRF) has revamped its fixed income portfolio.
Mercer backs alternatives »
Mercer has awarded $34.15 million in mandates to Tactical Global Management (TGM) and Lazard Asset Management to invest in alternative assets.
Here we go again. Unlike this time last week, we have little to focus on happening overseas to propel us out of these financial doldrums.... read more »
